Language:

Fighting Back: Reporting in times of censorship

In countries where freedom of press is nonexistent and where independent press is constantly under scrutiny, many journalists face obstacles to writing the kind of stories they want to. In such countries, self-censorship becomes a way of survival.

Should journalists write their stories despite government censorship or should they stop using their pen as a show of protest? What is the most conscientious action for a journalist confronted with the limitations of censorship? Are you in a country where you have to self-censor in order to survive as a journalist? What is your solution?

IJNet would like to hear your opinion. We invite you to answer these questions or add some of your own. Join the discussion by clicking on "Add a Comment" below. Please identify your country if possible. Thanks for your participation.

I am a 56-year-

I am a 56-year-old Cameroonian journalist who has held top editorial positions in several newspapers in my country. Currently I am the Editor-in-Chief/Publisher of the WEEKLY POST newspaper. Compared to yesteryears, the working environment for journalists in Cameroon has considerably improved. There is no pre-publication censorship per se now but journalists and newspaper owners have to self-censor if they must continue publishing. The big advertisers in the country are government and state corporations and the placement of advertisements is selective and based on how friendly the pens of media house writers are to government. As a long-serving Editor and Columnist, one sometimes is forced to drop certain stories or issues for fear of being perceived as leaning on the 'wrong' side, a perception that can cost the media house valuable advertising. Things could easily be better if production costs could be covered by sales, but since the slashing of public sector salaries by about 70% in 1993 print media sales have dropped by more than 80% so survival now depends largely on advertising. The couch is obvious.

One of rhe main

One of rhe main hurdle for the Journalist is censorship whether it directly or indirectly from the governent . censorship is required but not for hide the crime of rhe government or for to full lillment it's vested interest. Responcive journalism only can make the government responcible and people oriented. So, outhority should be given to the journalist for self-censorship in the media, but not any obstacle on rhe name of censorship.

Please see the

Please see the article on 'Can't write about big fish' in http://www2.fo.hik.se:16080/jd07/censorship.html

Can't write abo

Can't write about big fish

By - Mervis Senga, Syful Islam & Boussaina Kamel (Malawi, Bangladesh & Egypt)

Being seasoned journalists in our respective countries, we became interested in the whole question about censorship and self-censorship in the media. Through our exchange of experiences it was evident that though nowadays there is much talk about freedom of the press, one cannot do away with censorship and self-censorship.

Actually we wanted to freely express ourselves as much as possible so that we paint a clear picture of what censorship and self-censorship is all about in our countries. However, self-censorship militated against our wishes. Nobody amongst us wanted to be quoted verbatim, for fear of repercussions.

Sometimes journalists exercise self-censorship unnecessarily. There is always fear of the unknown among them and they think for instance they cannot criticise government or write bad about any government official.

For example, two years ago former Malawian Health Minister Yusuf Mwawa used public funds for his wedding reception. The story spread throughout Malawi like bush fire.

Private newspapers carried it on their front pages with a call for Mwawa to resign while for the private radio stations, the story became an automatic first headline.

But Jane Masina, a journalist who works for the Malawi Broadcasting Corporation (MBC), a state controlled radio station, had some fears to write about it. She thought it was not good and even dangerous to write against big fish in government.

Masina had courage to report on the matter only when the independent media had intensified their investigations about the case.

In most cases, Journalists at the Malawi Broadcasting Corporation end up leaking their news ideas to the independent press so that they can start the ball rolling and they follow. Its rare for MBC to break the news!

The same is true for Angela Chishimba a Zambian journalist working in a state controlled media. She deliberately avoids talking bad about the government or else the story will not be published. Chhay Channyda, a journalist from Cambodia has the same experience and she recalls a day when her boss asked her just to turn a blind eye on a story that involved the opposition.

Self-censorship emanates from censorship. One cannot dare to report on an issue that can attract the wrath of government or even the employer. ‘For us we often receive instructions from government not to report on certain issues. If we do, they think we are part of the Tamil Tigers’, said Uvindu Kurukulasuriya, a Journalist from Sri Lanka. Uvindu, however, said he found a way of dealing with censorship and this is to befriend his sources so that he gets closer to them.

And Bangladesh is currently in a state of emergency and nobody can criticise the military backed government. To this effect, Hamal magazine had its latest issue censored as its editorial clearly stated that the country was under fire.

The media in Malawi also has to follow set guidelines every now and then. Just recently private radio stations were barred from broadcasting live opposition rallies in the run up to the 2009 general elections. They have to seek prior permission from the Malawi Communications Regulatory Authority.

A similar scenario exists in Zimbabwe . The Access to Information and Protection of Privacy Act compels journalists to register with a government appointed body--- the Media and Information Commission which is biased against the independent media. “ So far four independent newspapers: The Daily News, The Daily News on Sunday, The weekly Times and The Tribune have been shut down since 2003 when the law was enacted’, said Zhean Gwaze, a Zimbabwean journalist

Zhean continued to say that Public Order and Security Act prohibits rallies and gatherings without police clearance. “ Due to this law, many journalists are caught in crossfire and arrested especially when they go to cover opposition rallies”, she said

Until last year journalists in Egypt were prohibited to write about ‘the three taboos’: the president and his family, religion and sex. Though some private media can now criticise the president and report on sexual issues, reporting on Islam remains a taboo. Recently Karim Amer was sentenced to four years imprisonment for insulting the president and Islam in his blog.

But whatever the case journalists have to strictly follow their ethics, censorship or no censorship.

Girmay Gebru V

Girmay Gebru VOA's reporter in Ethiopia If censorship no journalism. Most goverments want to censor every journalistic reports. In our country ,Ethiopia, there are the so called journalists they themselves allow officials to censor their reports. The draft law of press which allows censorship is still in its draft status. This is because of the strong oppostion from abroad and within. So, I strongly believe censorship is a virus to free press we don't have to protect it we should distroy it forever. We all must to stand against censorship.

Post new comment

Google Translate